Turkiye: Constitutional Court Declares Nurcan Kaya’s Travel Ban a Violation of Freedom of Speech
Women Press Freedom applauds this landmark ruling protecting journalists targeted with arbitrary bans
Location: Turkiye, Ankara
Date: March 5, 2024
In a groundbreaking decision, Turkiye's Constitutional Court ruled that a travel ban imposed on journalist and author Nurcan Kaya constitutes an infringement upon the constitutional right to freedom of expression. This landmark ruling marks the first time the court directly correlates judicial control, in the form of a travel ban, to a violation of freedom of speech. Women Press Freedom welcomes this decision, which bolsters press freedom, as we have documented authorities over and over again imposing travel bans on journalists who report critically of the state.
Read latest reports from the globe
WPF is deeply disturbed by the arrest of Nadezhda Kevorkova, a 65-year-old journalist known for her coverage of the Middle East and the North Caucasus.
WPF strongly condemns the unjust charges against Derya Us and Nurcan Yalçın who were arrested by police for allegedly belonging to a terrorist organization.
On March 5, 2024, Nurcan Kaya and her legal team from the Media and Law Studies Association (MLSA) won a significant victory in Turkiye’s Constitutional Court in Ankara. The judge determined that a travel ban issued to Kaya in 2019 for a tweet she posted was unconstitutional.
Veysel Ok, Co-Director of MLSA, praised the court’s decision, highlighting the escalating trend of Turkish courts imposing arbitrary judicial control measures on journalists, lawyers, and politicians, particularly in cases involving news and information sharing.
Nurcan Kaya was detained in October 2019 while attempting to leave Turkiye due to a tweet she posted in 2014 expressing solidarity with the people of Kobane, Syria. Despite being released after her interrogation; the authorities imposed an international travel ban against her. She was sentenced to one year and three months in prison in September 2021 on charges of propagandizing for a terrorist organization. Throughout her trial, she endured a 1.5-month-long period of judicial control, including a travel ban, which the Constitutional Court has now deemed an encroachment upon her fundamental right to freedom of expression.
The Constitutional Court deemed Kaya's tweet, made on the day of a Turkish military operation in Northern Syria, a matter of public interest falling within the realm of freedom of expression.
Critically, the court condemned the significant punitive effect of the travel ban on Kaya, especially given her involvement in international human rights activities. It chastised the Peace Criminal Judgeship for neglecting to explore less restrictive alternatives before imposing the ban and for dismissing an appeal against it on vague grounds.
The court also acknowledged the stifling effect of the judicial control decision on Kaya, awarding her 13,500 Turkish Liras (approximately $422) in moral damages for the violation of her rights.
This ruling serves as a beacon of hope for press freedom advocates and independent journalists in Turkiye, where critical press is frequently subjected to arbitrary travel bans. Judges must now justify imposing these measures; they cannot be handed down without proper reasoning. In a country where there is mass legal harassment of journalists, Women Press Freedom hopes that this ruling will have a positive impact on journalists facing trial. Journalists and activists must not be barred from travel without clear evidence to justify applying these restrictions. This ruling sets a precedent for judicial accountability and the protection of fundamental freedoms, signaling a step towards a more transparent and democratic society.
WPF strongly condemns the unjust charges against Derya Us and Nurcan Yalçın who were arrested by police for allegedly belonging to a terrorist organization.
Yet again, authorities have thrown Elif Akkuş behind bars, this time awaiting trial under accusations of evidence tampering, allegedly tied to her expenditure during coverage of conflicts in Libya and Syria while working for state-run broadcaster TRT.
WPF expresses deep concern over the actions of Turkish authorities during the May Day march in Istanbul's Saraçhane district.
WPF vehemently condemns the repeated and unfounded accusations against journalist Zeynep Kuray by Turkish authorities.
WPF strongly condemns the police raid following Kurdish Journalists' Day targeting journalists from Kurdish news outlets across Turkiye.
WPF condemns the prosecutor's decision to pursue charges against journalist Asena Tunca for allegedly "opposing the law on meetings and demonstrations" following her violent detention by law enforcement while covering a protest against the government's handling of the February 2024 earthquakes.
WPF condemns the investigation into Duygu Kıt for her coverage of opposition to a quarry construction close to a fatal mine collapse in İliç, Erzincan.
WPF expresses profound dismay at the relentless pursuit of journalist Ayşe Kara by the Diyarbakır prosecutor, who has gone to unjustifiable lengths to harass her.
WPF celebrates the release of Dilan Oyunş after an unjust seven-year imprisonment on spurious terrorism charges.
WPF condemns the threats and violence Medine Mamedoğlu endured as a direct consequence of her exposing police brutality during protests in Van.
WPF stands unwaveringly with Perihan Kaya, an exiled journalist facing retrial in Turkiye on unfounded terrorism charges.
WPF views the lawsuit by Deputy Ali İhsan Arslan of the ruling AKP party against İleri Haber journalists İzel Sezer and Doğan Ergün as an attempt to stifle critical journalism, and we call for the case to be dismissed.
Rojin Akın has been finally vindicated of “membership of a terrorist organization” charges.
WPF firmly condemns the recent assaults, intimidation, and detentions of journalists in Turkiye, as they covered the protests against the electoral authorities' decision to block a pro-Kurdish mayor-elect in Van despite his election victory.
WPF persistently monitored the electoral process during the local elections and noted multiple instances of infringements. We condemn acts of violence and restrictions, including against Ece Üner, who was threatened with death.
Women Press Freedom is deeply troubled by Elif Akgül facing a potential 13.5 years behind bars over two tweets in 2018 and 2022, respectively.
Women Press Freedom welcomes the decision by the Istanbul prosecutor to drop the investigation against Artı TV journalist Şükran Ekinci.
WPF denounces the court’s decision to convict Pınar Gayıp and Mehmet Acettin, journalists with the Etkin News Agency (ETHA), of “denigrating Turkishness” for their coverage of a lawyer accused of sexual harassment.
WPF condemns the charges brought against Zeynep Durgut, who was unjustly and forcibly arrested while she was covering a women's rights activist's press statement in November 2023.
WPF welcomes the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) ruling Turkiye violated the freedom, security, and freedom of expression rights of journalist Ayşenur Parıldak — exonerating the journalist and acknowledging the unjust sentence she endured.
WPF supports Yaşar's decision to file a complaint against police officers who subjected the journalist to physical assault, racist insults, and threats when they violently detained her.
WPF is appalled by the police violence and unjust detention of journalists covering the Kurdish New Year Celebrations (Nowruz) in Istanbul.
WPF welcomes the guilty verdict against the police officers for their violence against reporter Beyza Kural in Istanbul during her coverage of the YÖK protest in 2015.
In a groundbreaking decision, Turkiye's Constitutional Court ruled that a travel ban imposed on journalist and author Nurcan Kaya constitutes an infringement upon the constitutional right to freedom of expression.
The exoneration of documentary filmmaker Sibel Tekin from charges implicating her with a terrorist organization signifies the conclusion of a protracted legal ordeal that began with her detention in December 2022.
Dicle Müftüoğlu, editor at the pro-Kurdish Mezopotamya News Agency, has been held in pretrial detention for over 7 months on charges of membership and leadership in the Kurdistan Workers' Party (PKK), a group classified as a terrorist organization by the Turkish government.
Women Press Freedom welcomes court’s decision while urging an end to state’s abuse of anti-terror legislation to target journalist
WPF has been closely following the case against journalist Canan Coşkun in Turkiye and welcomes the recent court decision to drop all charges against her following a retrial.
WPF strongly condemns the ongoing legal proceedings against Gözde Bedeloğlu, a journalist for BirGün, who is currently facing charges of "insulting a public official" in Istanbul, Turkiye, filed by a Nationalist Movement Party politician.
WPF vehemently condemns the recent judgment against journalist Nagihan Yılkın, who was fined for "insulting a public official" following her investigative work into corruption involving the former Governor of Gaziantep, Turkiye.
Women Press Freedom is an initiative by The Coalition For Women In Journalism
The Coalition For Women In Journalism is a global organization of support for women journalists. The CFWIJ pioneered mentorship for mid-career women journalists across several countries around the world and is the first organization to focus on the status of free press for women journalists. We thoroughly document cases of any form of abuse against women in any part of the globe. Our system of individuals and organizations brings together the experience and mentorship necessary to help female career journalists navigate the industry. Our goal is to help develop a strong mechanism where women journalists can work safely and thrive.
If you have been harassed or abused in any way, and please report the incident by using the following form.